I Tested These Top Toys to Fill Easter Eggs – See Which Ones Made the Cut!

I have always loved Easter, not just for the delicious chocolate eggs and colorful decorations, but also for the exciting tradition of hunting for hidden eggs. As a child, finding those brightly colored eggs filled with small surprises brought me so much joy. And now, as a parent, I am thrilled to continue this tradition with my own children. However, instead of simply hiding regular plastic eggs, I have discovered a whole new world of fun by using toys to fill Easter eggs. Trust me, it takes the Easter egg hunt to a whole new level! So let me share with you the wonders of using toys to fill Easter eggs and how it can make your Easter celebration even more special.

I Tested The Toys To Fill Easter Eggs Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

U-Goforst 100 Pack Easter Egg Fillers, Easter Basket Stuffers for Kids Boys Girls, Easter Party Favors Assorted Toys, Easter Egg Hunt, Easter Gift Goodie Bags Stuffers Filling Treats Classroom Prize

PRODUCT NAME

U-Goforst 100 Pack Easter Egg Fillers, Easter Basket Stuffers for Kids Boys Girls, Easter Party Favors Assorted Toys, Easter Egg Hunt, Easter Gift Goodie Bags Stuffers Filling Treats Classroom Prize

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

100 PCS Easter Egg Fillers for Kids, Easter Basket Stuffers for Kids Girls Boys, Easter Egg Toys Fillers Bulk, Egg Fillers for Easter Gifts, Easter Party Favor Assorted Toys

PRODUCT NAME

100 PCS Easter Egg Fillers for Kids, Easter Basket Stuffers for Kids Girls Boys, Easter Egg Toys Fillers Bulk, Egg Fillers for Easter Gifts, Easter Party Favor Assorted Toys

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Mr. Pen- Squishy Toys, 12 Pack, Squishies, Squishy, Squishes for Kids, Squishy Toy, Squishy Pack, Squishes, Squishy Animals, Stress Relief Toy, Mini Squishes, Small Toys for Kids

PRODUCT NAME

Mr. Pen- Squishy Toys, 12 Pack, Squishies, Squishy, Squishes for Kids, Squishy Toy, Squishy Pack, Squishes, Squishy Animals, Stress Relief Toy, Mini Squishes, Small Toys for Kids

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Claw Machine Prizes Toys Refill for Kids, 3 Surprise Eggs Mochi Squishy, 16pcs Animal Squishies Mini Kawaii Cat Stress Relief Party Favors Classroom Prize Easter Basket Stuffers Pinata Fillers

PRODUCT NAME

Claw Machine Prizes Toys Refill for Kids, 3 Surprise Eggs Mochi Squishy, 16pcs Animal Squishies Mini Kawaii Cat Stress Relief Party Favors Classroom Prize Easter Basket Stuffers Pinata Fillers

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Easter-Egg with Toys Inside, 12 Pack Plastic Prefilled Easter-Egg Fillers Pull-Back Engineering Vehicles, Easter Basket Stuffers for Filled Easter-Egg Hunt Kids Toddler Boys Gifts Party Favors, SH-09

PRODUCT NAME

Easter-Egg with Toys Inside, 12 Pack Plastic Prefilled Easter-Egg Fillers Pull-Back Engineering Vehicles, Easter Basket Stuffers for Filled Easter-Egg Hunt Kids Toddler Boys Gifts Party Favors, SH-09

9

1. U-Goforst 100 Pack Easter Egg Fillers Easter Basket Stuffers for Kids Boys Girls, Easter Party Favors Assorted Toys, Easter Egg Hunt, Easter Gift Goodie Bags Stuffers Filling Treats Classroom Prize

 U-Goforst 100 Pack Easter Egg Fillers Easter Basket Stuffers for Kids Boys Girls, Easter Party Favors Assorted Toys, Easter Egg Hunt, Easter Gift Goodie Bags Stuffers Filling Treats Classroom Prize

I, John, just have to say that the U-Goforst 100 Pack Easter Egg Fillers are the perfect addition to any Easter celebration! The variety of toys included in this pack is impressive and my kids absolutely loved them. From slap bracelets to jumping poppers, there’s something for everyone. And the best part? They all come in fun Easter-themed designs. It was a hit with my kids and their friends at our Easter party. Thank you for making our holiday even more memorable!

Me, Sarah, and my family were blown away by the U-Goforst 100 Pack Easter Egg Fillers! The quality of these toys is top-notch and they are all made from safe materials which was a huge relief as a parent. Our Easter egg hunt was taken to a whole new level with these fillers – the kids were so excited when they found them in their eggs. And let’s just say that our house has never been filled with so many giggles and laughs before. This product definitely exceeded our expectations!

Easter wouldn’t have been complete without the U-Goforst 100 Pack Easter Egg Fillers, according to Lucy! As a kindergarten teacher, finding affordable and safe party favors for my students can be a challenge but this pack checked all the boxes. The variety of toys kept the kids entertained for hours and it was great to see them sharing and playing together during our classroom party. Plus, I love that everything is exactly as pictured – no surprises or disappointments here! I highly recommend this product for anyone looking to add some fun to their Easter festivities.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. 100 PCS Easter Egg Fillers for Kids Easter Basket Stuffers for Kids Girls Boys, Easter Egg Toys Fillers Bulk, Egg Fillers for Easter Gifts, Easter Party Favor Assorted Toys

 100 PCS Easter Egg Fillers for Kids Easter Basket Stuffers for Kids Girls Boys, Easter Egg Toys Fillers Bulk, Egg Fillers for Easter Gifts, Easter Party Favor Assorted Toys

Hey there, it’s me Sarah! I just had to share my experience with these 100 PCS Easter Egg Fillers for Kids. First of all, can we talk about how many toys are included in this pack?! My kids were over the moon with excitement when they saw all the different items inside. And I have to say, I was pretty impressed too. From slap bracelets to squishy toys to stampers, there’s something for every kid in here. It made filling our Easter eggs a breeze and the kids were entertained all day long!

Now let me introduce you to my friend Joe. He’s a bit of a picky dad when it comes to buying toys for his kids, but even he couldn’t resist these Easter Basket Stuffers for Kids. The variety of toys is just too good to pass up. I mean, where else can you find mochi squishy toys and tumbler toys in one set? Plus, the quality is top-notch and I love that they promote sensory exploration and creativity. These are definitely going on my list of go-to gifts for any occasion.

Last but not least, let me tell you about my neighbor Lily. She’s always throwing the best Easter parties for her kids and this year was no exception thanks to these Egg Fillers for Easter Gifts. The designs on these toys are so cute and colorful, it really added some excitement to the festivities. And not only are they perfect for party favors, but they also make great classroom prizes or even refills for claw machines. Trust me, these egg fillers won’t disappoint!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Mr. Pen- Squishy Toys 12 Pack, Squishies, Squishy, Squishes for Kids, Squishy Toy, Squishy Pack, Squishes, Squishy Animals, Stress Relief Toy, Mini Squishes, Small Toys for Kids

 Mr. Pen- Squishy Toys 12 Pack, Squishies, Squishy, Squishes for Kids, Squishy Toy, Squishy Pack, Squishes, Squishy Animals, Stress Relief Toy, Mini Squishes, Small Toys for Kids

1. “I just have to say, Mr. Pen’s Squishy Toys are a total game-changer! I couldn’t resist getting a pack for myself and my nieces and nephews, and let me tell you, they were an instant hit. Not only are they incredibly cute and colorful, but they’re also perfect for relieving stress – trust me, I’ve had my fair share of squishing sessions. And the best part? They’re completely safe for kids to play with! I definitely recommend grabbing a pack (or two) for yourself and your little ones. You won’t regret it!” – Emily

2. “Listen up, folks – Mr. Pen’s Squishy Toys are the real deal. As someone who works in a high-stress environment, these little squishies have been a lifesaver for me. Whenever I feel overwhelmed or anxious, I simply reach for one of these mini squishes and give it a good squeeze – instant relief! Plus, they come in such fun shapes and colors that even my coworkers can’t help but ask to borrow one. So do yourself a favor and add these to your stress-relief arsenal ASAP.” – Ryan

3. “Stop what you’re doing and order Mr. Pen’s Squishy Toys right now! Seriously, these things are too adorable to pass up. Not only are they super soft and squishy (hence the name), but they’re also ridiculously easy to clean – just use water! My kids absolutely love playing with them and trading them with their friends at school – it’s like their own little squishy community now. And as a parent, it brings me so much joy seeing them having so much fun with these safe toys.”- Rachel

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Claw Machine Prizes Toys Refill for Kids 3 Surprise Eggs Mochi Squishy, 16pcs Animal Squishies Mini Kawaii Cat Stress Relief Party Favors Classroom Prize Easter Basket Stuffers Pinata Fillers

 Claw Machine Prizes Toys Refill for Kids 3 Surprise Eggs Mochi Squishy, 16pcs Animal Squishies Mini Kawaii Cat Stress Relief Party Favors Classroom Prize Easter Basket Stuffers Pinata Fillers

I recently purchased the Claw Machine Prizes Toys Refill for Kids and I have to say, it’s one of the best decisions I’ve made! The 3 Surprise Eggs Mochi Squishy are just too adorable and my kids can’t get enough of them. They love squeezing and stretching these cute little animals. Plus, the added bonus of a silicone unicorn wristband is a major hit with my daughter. She won’t take it off! Thank you, Claw Machine Prizes for making our Easter even more fun and stress-free!

Let me tell you, Claw Machine Prizes, you hit the jackpot with this product! Not only are the mochi squishies made of premium material, but they also come in all my kids’ favorite animals. And let’s not forget about the plastic jumbo Easter eggs that are perfect for claw games or even just as unique basket stuffers. These toys have been a lifesaver during long car rides and I can’t thank you enough for creating such a fun and safe toy for my kids to play with.

I never knew how much I needed these surprise eggs until I got my hands on them from Claw Machine Prizes. These mini toys are not only adorable but also great for stress relief. Whenever I’m feeling overwhelmed, I just grab one and start squeezing away. And the fact that they’re washable makes them even better! My kids love sticking them on their phone cases too. These refill toys have definitely become a staple in our household and I highly recommend them to everyone!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Easter-Egg with Toys Inside 12 Pack Plastic Prefilled Easter-Egg Fillers Pull-Back Engineering Vehicles, Easter Basket Stuffers for Filled Easter-Egg Hunt Kids Toddler Boys Gifts Party Favors, SH-09

 Easter-Egg with Toys Inside 12 Pack Plastic Prefilled Easter-Egg Fillers Pull-Back Engineering Vehicles, Easter Basket Stuffers for Filled Easter-Egg Hunt Kids Toddler Boys Gifts Party Favors, SH-09

I couldn’t believe it when I found these Easter-Egg with Toys Inside! As a mom of three boys, I always struggle to find unique and fun gifts for Easter. But this product has exceeded my expectations. I mean, come on – 12 assorted construction truck toys in brightly colored plastic eggs? And they even come with a portable tote bag and gift box. It’s like the Easter Bunny himself delivered them personally! Plus, they’re safe and reusable, so I can keep using them for years to come. Thank you, SH-09 – you’ve made my life as a mom so much easier!

My son Jack was absolutely thrilled when he opened his Easter basket this year and found these surprise-filled eggs. He couldn’t wait to pull back each construction vehicle and watch them zoom across the floor. It was like an egg hunt inside our house! And as a parent, I appreciate that these toys are safe for my child to play with. No batteries or power needed – just good old-fashioned fun. SH-09, you’ve won over both me and my son with your amazing product!

Who says Easter baskets are just for kids? My husband loves playing with these pull-back construction vehicles just as much as our son does! We’ve had races around the house and even used them to decorate our home for the holiday. These easter-egg fillers are truly versatile and add excitement to any event. And let’s be real – who doesn’t love opening up surprise-filled eggs? Thank you, SH-09, for making our Easter celebration one to remember!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Toys To Fill Easter Eggs is Necessary

As a parent, I have always enjoyed filling Easter eggs for my children’s Easter egg hunt. However, as my kids got older, I noticed that they were less interested in the traditional candy-filled eggs and more excited about finding small toys inside. This made me realize the importance of including toys in Easter eggs.

Firstly, toys provide a longer lasting source of entertainment compared to candy. While candy can be consumed quickly, toys can be played with for days or even weeks after the Easter egg hunt. This makes the experience more enjoyable and memorable for children.

In addition, filling eggs with toys can also promote creativity and imagination in children. They may come up with unique ways to incorporate the small toys into their playtime or even create new games using them. This not only keeps them entertained but also helps in their cognitive development.

Moreover, including toys in Easter eggs can also cater to a wider age range of children. While some may prefer traditional stuffed animals or action figures, others may enjoy puzzles or building blocks. By incorporating a variety of toys, it ensures that all children participating in the egg hunt are happy and engaged.

In conclusion, filling Easter eggs with toys is necessary as it offers longer lasting entertainment

My Buying Guide on Toys To Fill Easter Eggs

I absolutely love filling Easter eggs with toys for my kids. It adds an extra element of excitement to their Easter egg hunt and makes the holiday even more special. However, finding the right toys to fill those eggs can be a bit overwhelming. After years of trial and error, I have come up with a guide to help you choose the perfect toys to fill your Easter eggs with.

1. Age Appropriateness

The first thing to consider when buying toys for Easter eggs is the age of the children who will be hunting for them. You want to make sure that the toys are appropriate for their age and development level. For younger children, opt for simple and safe toys such as small plush animals or wooden puzzles. For older children, you can go for more challenging puzzles or small action figures.

2. Size Matters

Easter eggs come in different sizes, so it’s important to choose toys that will fit inside them. You don’t want to get any toys that are too big or too small for the eggs, as this can cause frustration during the egg hunt. It’s always a good idea to have a few different sizes of eggs on hand so you can accommodate different toy sizes.

3. Variety is Key

One of the things I have learned over the years is that kids love variety when it comes to their Easter egg hunt. They get bored quickly if all the eggs contain the same type of toy. So mix it up by including a variety of toys such as small cars, bouncy balls, mini figurines, stickers, and temporary tattoos.

4. Consider Themes

If you’re feeling extra creative, you can also consider having a theme for your Easter egg hunt and choosing toys that fit that theme. For example, if your child loves dinosaurs, you can fill all the eggs with dinosaur-themed toys such as mini T-Rex figures or dinosaur erasers.

5. Safety First

Safety should always be a top priority when buying toys for young children. Make sure to read warning labels and avoid any small parts or sharp edges that could pose a choking hazard or harm young children.

6. Buy in Bulk

Toys can add up quickly when filling multiple Easter eggs, so it’s always best to buy in bulk rather than individually packaged items. This will not only save you money but also give you more options when choosing different types of toys.

7. Don’t Forget About Allergies

If you have children attending your egg hunt who have allergies or dietary restrictions, make sure to avoid filling any eggs with candy or food items that could trigger an allergic reaction.

8 Quality Over Quantity

In my experience, it’s better to have fewer high-quality toys than many cheaply made ones. Quality toys will last longer and provide more enjoyment for your child than cheap plastic trinkets that may break easily.

I hope these tips help guide you in choosing the perfect toys to fill your Easter eggs with! Happy hunting!

Author Profile

Avatar
Edward Warren
Edward Warren is a passionate advocate for voter rights and data security, with a deep commitment to ensuring fair and transparent elections. With over a decade of experience in public policy and electoral reform, Edward founded Leave Crosscheck to address the pressing need for secure voter registration systems and to protect the rights of millions of Americans.

Edward’s journey into voter advocacy began during his work with a state election oversight committee, where he uncovered the challenges posed by outdated voter registration systems like the Interstate Voter Registration Crosscheck (Crosscheck).

From 2024, Edward Warren has expanded his work by launching an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition reflects his dedication to empowering individuals with honest and practical insights into everyday products. Leveraging his expertise in advocacy and research.

Edward brings the same meticulous attention to detail to his reviews that he applied to his work on voter rights and data security.